First Internet Bancorp (NASDAQ: NASDAQ:INBK) has revealed substantial financial growth in the third quarter of 2024, marking its fourth consecutive quarter of double-digit earnings expansion. The bank reported a 21% increase in net income quarter-over-quarter, with a significant surge in revenue and strong loan performance. Management remains confident about the company's financial trajectory, as reflected in their outlook for the coming quarters, citing favorable market conditions and strategic initiatives.
Key Takeaways
- Net income rose to $7 million, a 21% increase from the previous quarter, with diluted earnings per share growing 19% to $0.80.
- Operating revenue saw a 4% increase from the prior quarter and a 36% year-over-year rise, bolstered by net interest income and non-interest income, particularly from SBA lending.
- Loan origination yields held steady at 8.85%, with a 25% annual increase in net interest income and a loan-to-deposit ratio improvement to 84%.
- Average deposits grew by 5%, with a 12% increase from the previous quarter, largely driven by fintech partnerships and CD production.
- SBA loan originations jumped 35% year-to-date, making the bank the eighth largest SBA 7(a) lender in the U.S.
- Credit quality remained solid, with a slight uptick in nonperforming loans, which now represent 56 basis points of total loans.
- Tangible book value increased by 3.6% in Q3 and nearly 11% year-over-year.
Company Outlook
- Management anticipates continued earnings momentum into Q4, supported by a favorable loan portfolio composition and lower deposit costs following Fed rate cuts.
- The bank projects a 1.5% to 2% increase in loan balances and a 10% to 15% rise in net interest income for Q4 2024.
- Net interest margin is expected to be between 1.8% and 1.85%, with SBA originations forecasted to grow 15% to 20% in 2025.
Bearish Highlights
- Nonperforming loans have seen a slight increase.
- Non-interest expenses rose due to higher salaries and staffing.
- Secondary market price drops could impact loan sales, although the bank remains confident in its liquidity position.
Bullish Highlights
- The bank's SBA platform continues to thrive with a 35% increase in loan originations.
- Management expects a conservative estimate of at least 10 basis points of margin expansion per quarter in 2025, potentially leading to an increase in net interest income.
- Opportunities for acquiring FinTech firms as traditional institutions pull back could present significant growth opportunities.
Misses
- The bank noted modest declines in SBA delinquencies after a peak in July.
- Consumer delinquencies remained under 1%, with no significant issues in major retail chains.
Q&A Highlights
- Management addressed actions taken on loans overdue by 90 days, particularly in the small business and franchise sectors.
- Ken Lovik discussed net interest margin growth expectations and the impact of potential Federal Reserve rate cuts.
- David Becker reaffirmed the goal of achieving $3 in income for 2024 and potential growth to $4 in 2025, contingent on stable political conditions.
First Internet Bancorp's latest earnings call paints a picture of a bank on the ascent, with a clear strategy in place to sustain growth and navigate market challenges. With a robust increase in net income and a confident outlook from management, the bank appears well-positioned to capitalize on emerging opportunities and deliver on its financial targets for the current year and beyond.
InvestingPro Insights
First Internet Bancorp's strong financial performance in Q3 2024 is further supported by data from InvestingPro. The company's market capitalization stands at $302.25 million, reflecting its solid position in the banking sector. Notably, INBK's revenue growth of 26.53% over the last twelve months aligns with the impressive 36% year-over-year increase in operating revenue reported in the earnings call.
The bank's profitability is underscored by its attractive P/E ratio of 13.89, which is particularly appealing when considering the company's growth prospects. This is reinforced by an InvestingPro Tip indicating that INBK is trading at a low P/E ratio relative to its near-term earnings growth potential.
Another InvestingPro Tip highlights that net income is expected to grow this year, which corroborates management's optimistic outlook for continued earnings momentum into Q4 and beyond. This positive trend is further supported by the bank's strong return on investment, with a remarkable 141.82% price total return over the past year.
It's worth noting that First Internet Bancorp has maintained dividend payments for 13 consecutive years, as pointed out by another InvestingPro Tip. This demonstrates the company's commitment to shareholder returns and financial stability, even as it pursues growth opportunities.
For investors seeking a more comprehensive analysis, InvestingPro offers 8 additional tips for First Internet Bancorp, providing a deeper understanding of the company's financial health and market position.
Full transcript - First Internet Bancorp (INBK) Q3 2024:
Operator: Good day, everyone, and welcome to the First Internet Bancorp Earnings Conference Call for the Third Quarter of 2024. At this time, all lines are in a listen-only mode. Following the presentation we will conduct a question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions] Please note that today's event is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Ben Brodkowitz from Financial Profiles, Inc. Ben, please go ahead.
Ben Brodkowitz: Thank you, Sylvie. Hello, everyone, and thank you for joining us to discuss First Internet Bancorp's third quarter financial results. The company issued its earnings press release yesterday afternoon, and it is available on the company's website at www.firstinternetbancorp.com. In addition, the company has included a slide presentation that you can refer to during this call. You can also access these slides on the website. Joining us today from the management team are Chairman and CEO, David Becker; and Executive Vice President and CFO, Ken Lovik. David will provide an overview, and Ken will discuss the financial results. Then we'll open up the call to your questions. Before we begin, I’d like to remind you that this conference call contains forward-looking statements with respect to the future performance and financial condition of First Internet Bancorp that involve risks and uncertainties. Various factors could cause actual results to be materially different from any future results expressed or implied by such forward-looking statements. These factors are discussed in the company's SEC filings, which are available on the company's website. The company disclaims any obligation to update any forward-looking statements made during this call. Additionally, management may refer to non-GAAP measures, which are intended to supplement, but not substitute for the most directly comparable GAAP measures. The press release, available on the website, contains the financial and other quantitative information to be discussed today, as well as the reconciliation of the GAAP to non-GAAP measures. At this time, I'd like to turn the call over to David.
David Becker: Thank you, Ben. Good afternoon everyone, and thanks for joining us today as we discuss our third quarter 2024 results. We have turned in four consecutive quarters of double-digit earnings growth and improved profitability for the company, driven in large part by the recovery in our margin and the growth in net interest income that we projected at this time last year. Our third quarter results were strong in virtually all areas. Increase in net interest income was driven by solid loan growth, a larger balance sheet and higher yields on our earning assets, anchored by continued stabilization in funding costs. Strong growth in non-interest income was powered by continued expansion of our national SBA platform with a record gain on sale revenue. In short, the revenue side of the equation is firing on all cylinders with total operating revenue growth of over 4% compared to the prior quarter and up over 36% year-over-year. At the same time, our efforts to improve the risk profile of the company are also bearing fruit. The exceptionally strong deposit growth in conjunction with the ongoing and deliberate shift in our loan mix have increased our balance sheet flexibility. Our balance sheet liquidity is measured by the loan-to-deposit ratio is the strongest it's been in recent history. Starting with the highlights on Slide 3. I would like to discuss some key themes for the quarter in more detail. As a result of our continued improvement in operating performance, we reported net income of $7 million, up 21% and diluted earnings per share of $0.80, up over 19% from the second quarter's reported results. Compared to the second quarter's adjusted results, net income was up over 12% and earnings per share was up over 11%, which as I noted a moment ago marks the fourth consecutive quarter of double-digits earnings growth. Our earnings growth was driven by continued expansion of non-interest income and gain on sale revenue to complement our sustained growth in net interest income. The excess liquidity created by the robust deposit growth caused a short-term drag on net interest margin. But it provides us a great deal of balance sheet flexibility that will be useful to us over the next two quarters. On the lending side, new funded loan origination yields were 8.85% consistent with the prior quarter. The yield on overall loan portfolio increased 7 basis points from the second quarter with deposit costs increased only 1 basis point. As a result, net interest income was up over 2% from the prior quarter. Furthermore, compared to the third quarter of 2023, net interest income was up 25% and net interest margin expanded by 21 basis points on a fully taxable equivalent basis. We remain confident that net income will continue to trend higher in the fourth quarter, as we experienced a full quarter's impact of the September Fed rate cut on deposit costs and we continue to improve the composition of the loan portfolio. We also expect that net interest margin will rebound as we deploy liquidity to fund both loan growth and maturing higher cost CDs and wholesale funding. A key driver in our efforts to reposition the loan portfolio and diversify our revenue is our small business lending team which delivered another standout quarter. The team continues to perform remarkably well, delivering strong production volume and another record quarter of gain on sale revenue. Compared to 2023 year-to-date SBA loan originations are up 35% and sold loan volume is up almost 60%, demonstrating the tangible results of the investment we have made in providing growth capital to entrepreneurs and small business owners throughout the country. Our small business pipeline continues to flourish and we are proud to announce that we were the eighth largest SBA 7(a) lender in the country for the SBA's 2024 fiscal year which ended on September 30th. Congratulations to our SBA team on another impressive quarter. The growth of our SBA business propels noninterest income which now comprises one-third of total revenue year-to-date compared to 25% for the comparable period last year. Bank-wide, we drove a 4% increase in total revenue over the prior quarter, our fifth consecutive quarter of revenue growth and continued improved profitability. Moving to the asset quality. Our overall credit quality remains sound despite an increase in nonperforming loans during the quarter. Nonperforming loans to total loans were 56 basis points and nonperforming assets to total assets were 39 basis points at quarter end. The increase in nonperformers is due to additions in franchise finance small business lending and residential mortgage. Our metrics still compare favorably to similar-sized banks. Furthermore, we have specific reserves on about 45% of the total nonperforming loan balance. Net charge-offs to average loans remain low at 15 basis points and were driven primarily by SBA charge-offs. A key measure of our focus on shareholder value creation is growth in the tangible book value per share which increased by 3.6% in the third quarter and is up almost 11% year-over-year. Since 2018, First Internet has grown tangible book value per share by more than 55%. We are among just a handful of banks that have grown tangible book value per share in each of the past five years which is a testament to our prudent balance sheet management and operational discipline through some very challenging periods for the industry. Turning now to Slide 4. I'll spend a couple of minutes discussing our lending activity during the quarter. We produced solid loan growth of 7.5% on an annualized basis for the quarter. Growth was led by our commercial lending teams where balances were up almost $75 million from the second quarter or 9.6% on an annualized basis. Our construction team had another solid quarter originating over $94 million in new commitments. Late in the third quarter $71 million of construction balances converted to investor commercial real estate due to the projects being substantially complete. In the aggregate construction and investor commercial real estate balances grew $84 million. At the quarter end, total unfunded commitments in our construction line of business were $515 million. As those projects progress draws on these loans in the upcoming months combined with the optionality to deploy excess liquidity to hold a portion of our SBA originations on our balance sheet will play a meaningful role in the continued shift of our loan portfolio towards higher-yielding variable rate loans. On the consumer side balances were up modestly as new originations in our specialty consumer channels were offset by declines in the residential mortgage and home equity balances. We focus on the super prime borrower and our consumer lending and rates on new production remained in the mid-8% range consistent with the second quarter. Furthermore delinquencies in these portfolios remain extremely low at under 1 basis points of total loans. To wrap up my comments, we continue to build off the last nine months of improving performance and delivered another solid quarter. We remain confident in the earnings momentum we have built, and are excited to end the year on a high note. Liquidity, asset quality and capital levels remain sound, with the continued evolution of our loan portfolio and greater revenue diversification, combined with expected declines in deposit costs following the first wave of Fed rate cuts, we believe we are well positioned to continue to achieve higher earnings and improved profitability in the fourth quarter and into 2025. Now, I'd like to turn the call over to Ken for more details on our financial results for the quarter.
Ken Lovik: Thanks David. As David covered the loan portfolio, let's turn to slides 5 and 6, where I will cover deposits in more detail. The average balance of deposits increased over $211 million, or 5% during the third quarter, and period-end deposits were up almost $524 million, or 12% from the prior quarter driven by growth in CD production and fintech partnership deposits. Non-maturity deposits were up almost $123 million, or 6% which reflects the increase in fintech partnership deposits. Additionally, total deposits from our fintech partners, including those classified as broker deposits were up 35% from the second quarter, and totaled $507 million at quarter end. Additionally, these partners generated almost $11.4 billion in payments volume, which was up 34% from the volume we produced in the second quarter. Total fintech partnership revenue was $771,000 in the third quarter which was up over 30% from the second quarter as contributions from one of our key partnerships began to scale up during the quarter. Related to CD activity during the quarter total balances were up $281 million, or 15% from the linked-quarter, driven by continued strong demand in the consumer channel. We originated $697 million in new production and renewals during the third quarter at an average cost of 4.77%, and a weighted average term of 21 months. These were partially offset by maturities of $391 million, with an average cost of 5.05%. Looking forward, we have $238 million of CDs maturing in the fourth quarter of 2024, with an average cost of 5.01% and $407 million maturing in the first quarter of 2025, with an average cost of 5.08%. CD pricing broke through its inflection point during the third quarter as the weighted average cost of new CDs was 28 basis points lower than the cost of maturing CDs. As interest rates across the yield curve began falling ahead of the expected cut in the Fed funds rate, we reduced CD rates significantly throughout the quarter. Accordingly, the weighted average cost of CD production during the month of December was 4.45% or over 30 basis points lower than the average cost of new CDs for the quarter. This is also 56 basis points lower than the rates on CDs maturing in the fourth quarter of 2024. With the combination of CDs repricing at lower rates and the cost of high beta deposits coming down 50 basis points, we feel confident that deposit pricing has hit its peak and will trend downward in the fourth quarter. Moving to slide 6. At quarter end, with the heightened level of deposit growth total liquidity remained very strong reflecting cash and unused borrowing capacity of $2.1 billion. We deployed some of the liquidity to pay down FHLB borrowings as well as to fund loan growth and securities purchases during the quarter. With total deposit balances increasing 12% and loan growth of $75 million, or about 2% the loans-to-deposits ratio declined to 84% from 93% at the end of the second quarter. At quarter end, our cash and unused borrowing capacity represented 179% of total uninsured deposits and 230% of adjusted uninsured deposits. Turning to slide 7 and 8. Net interest income for the quarter was $21.8 million and $22.9 million on a fully taxable equivalent basis, up 2.1% and 1.8% respectively from the second quarter. The yield on average interest-earning assets increased to 5.58% from 5.54% in the linked quarter, due primarily to a 7 basis point increase in the yield earned on loans, but partially offset by a decline in the yield earned on other earning assets. The higher yield on the loan portfolio combined with higher average loans, securities and cash balances produced solid top line growth in interest income, increasing 5.7% compared to the linked quarter. Factoring in the strong growth in average interest-bearing deposit balances, net interest income was up over 2% during the quarter, building on last quarter's increase and further distancing us from the low point in the third quarter of 2023, as shown in the bar chart on Slide 7. Net interest margin for the third quarter was 1.62% and 1.70% on a fully taxable equivalent basis, decreases of 5 and 6 basis points respectively from the second quarter. The net interest margin roll forward on Slide 8 highlights the drivers of change in fully taxable equivalent net interest margin during the quarter. Similar to last quarter, I'd like to clarify one item on this chart. The impact on deposits -- the impact of deposits on net interest margin is more a factor of dollar volume than rate. That is as I mentioned earlier, average interest-bearing deposits were up over $211 million during the quarter whereas average loan balances were up only $93 million. As David referenced in his comments, net interest margin for the quarter was impacted by carrying higher cash balances. We estimate that the excess liquidity negatively impacted net interest margin by six basis points. However, the elevated on-balance sheet liquidity also provides a great deal of flexibility going forward. As I mentioned moments ago, we have over $600 million of higher cost CDs maturing over the next two quarters as well as nearly $250 million of higher cost broker deposits maturing over that same time period. Furthermore, we estimate that loan activity primarily early payoffs of higher-yielding loans and loans with premiums had an additional negative impact on net interest margin of 6 basis points. However, loan pipelines remain solid, especially in the small business lending and construction lines of business, and our focus on improving the composition of our loan portfolio gives us further confidence that net interest income will continue to increase in future quarters. Related to deposits, looking at the graph on Slide 8 that tracks our monthly rate on interest-bearing deposits against the Fed funds rate, you can see the stability in deposit costs over the last several months. As I mentioned a few minutes ago, with the recent cut in the Fed funds rate and other short-term rates following suit as well as lower CD pricing across the maturity curve, we anticipate that interest-bearing deposit costs will begin trending downward in the fourth quarter. This should also drive further net interest income growth and provide a strong catalyst for net interest margin expansion. Turning to non-interest income on Slide 9. Non-interest income for the quarter was $12 million up $1 million or 9% from the second quarter. Gain on sale of loans totaled $9.9 million for the quarter, up 20% over the second quarter, setting another quarterly record for our SBA team. We originated over $163 million of SBA loans during the quarter, an increase of 42% over the linked quarter. Furthermore, loan sale volume was $126.5 million, up 22% while net gain on sale premium saw a decline of 65 basis points. Other non-interest income declined from the prior quarter to $1.1 million, due primarily to lower distributions received from fund investments. These decreases were partially offset by a modest increase in net loan servicing revenue. Moving to Slide 10. Non-interest expense for the quarter was $22.8 million up $450,000 from the second quarter. When you exclude non-recurring costs of almost $600,000 from the second quarter's results, operating expenses were up $1 million or 4.7%. The increase was due almost entirely to an increase in salaries and employee benefits driven by higher small business lending commissions in line with the higher volume of originations. Additionally, we added staff to our small business lending and risk management teams as we continue to build bench strength to support further growth. Turning to asset quality on Slide 11. David covered the major components of asset quality for the quarter in his comments so I will just add some commentary around the allowance for credit losses and provision for credit losses. The allowance for credit losses as a percentage of total loans was 1.13% at the end of the third quarter, up three basis points from the second quarter. The increase in the allowance for credit losses reflects growth in the loan portfolio and continued shift in the composition of the loan portfolio towards certain loan types with higher coverage ratios. The increase also reflected additional reserves related to small business and franchise loans. Provision for credit losses in the third quarter was $3.4 million compared to $4 million in the second quarter. The provision for the third quarter was driven by loan growth and changes in the loan portfolio composition, net charge-offs and the additional reserves related to small business and franchise lending. If you exclude the balances and reserves on our public finance and residential mortgage portfolios, which have lower coverage ratios given their lower inherent risk, the allowance for credit losses represented 1.35% of loan balances. Furthermore as a reminder with minimal office exposure, we do not have the excess reserves for that asset class that many other banks require. Moving to capital on slide 12. Our overall capital levels at both the company and the bank remain solid. The tangible common equity ratio was 6.54%, which experienced a decline due primarily to the strong deposit growth during the quarter and the increase in cash balances. If you exclude accumulated other comprehensive loss and adjust for normalized cash balances of $300 million, the adjusted tangible common equity ratio would be 7.49%. From a regulatory capital perspective, the common equity Tier one capital ratio remains solid at 9.37%. Before I wrap up, I'd like to provide some updates on our outlook for the fourth quarter of 2024. With regard to net interest income as I mentioned earlier with a solid loan pipeline, we expect loan balances to be up another 1.5% to 2% in the fourth quarter, while the all-in yield on the portfolio should be up a few basis points as origination volume is expected to outweigh the impact of recent rate cuts. Additionally, we expect the rate cuts to have a positive impact on the cost of funds related to deposits, although dollars of interest expense may be up a little bit due to the increase in average balances. However, top line interest income growth should far outweigh the dollar growth in deposit costs with net interest income increasing in the range of 10% to 15% on a quarterly basis. We also expect net interest margin to rebound and resume an upward trajectory. While the elevated cash balances will still weigh on margin expansion in the near-term, we expect fully taxable equivalent net interest margin to be in the range of 1.8% to 1.85% for the fourth quarter. And related to non-interest income and non-interest expense, our view remains consistent with our comments on last quarter's call. With the combination of our SBA team continuing to deliver consistently higher origination activity, our outlook remains extremely optimistic and we expect gain on sale revenue to be in the range of this quarter's elevated results. On the expense side, we expect continued growth in the salaries and employee benefits line item as we build further bench strength in risk management and small business lending especially as we plan for SBA origination growth in the range of 15% to 20% for 2025. Furthermore, we have technology investments slated for the fourth quarter, many of which pertain to further enhancing the digital experience and adding product features for our consumers in small business. With that, I will turn it back to the operator so we can take your questions.
Operator: Thank you, sir. [Operator Instructions] And your first question will be from Brett Rabatin at Hovde Group. Please go ahead.
Brett Rabatin: Hey guys, good afternoon.
David Becker: Hi, Brett.
Brett Rabatin: Hi. I wanted to start with just the comments or the franchise finance and the small business loans that were either past due or moved to non-accrual. Can you give us some additional color on what components of franchise finance that was? What small business is doing? And then just maybe any comments on the RV portfolio? And I know like Walgreens and CVS have also had some recent mentions of store closures, et cetera?
Ken Lovik: With regards to like in the franchise and small business, Brett. So on the franchise side, we've just had a handful of delinquencies there mostly having to do with certain brands and closures of units, trying to work with the borrowers to get them to the table to restructure a loan, pay off the loan that we just -- we've had to take some action on and move to non-accrual since they went 90 days past due. Probably not a common theme other than what you're hearing across the industry as far as restaurants and other retail entities struggling a bit. But we just had to take action on a pool of those loans that hit 90 days. On small business, there's really no consistent theme amongst them. In small business it's like every credit is a story. But kind of similar along the lines of franchise just had either businesses closing or struggling. Again, where we've had to kind of take action and maybe where we've offered a deferral or two and the borrower is struggling. So we just have to move it to non-accrual and work with the SBA to repurchase the loan and work with the borrower to finalize an exit strategy.
David Becker: Yeah. The ApplePie stuff is really our internal policy. When it hits 90 days as Ken said, we move it to non-accrual. We take a specific reserve against it. I don't know that the portfolio as he said, the loans are that bad. It's more an internal policy. We've had a tough time working with --they service the loans or have a third-party servicer work on the loans. They're not really incented to do anything, until the loans hit that 90-day bucket and they get $0.35 on the dollar of everything they recover. So we're coming at this from different viewpoints. They wanted to get delinquent so they can pick up a little income. We want to be at the front of the food chain when things go south. So we're re-negotiating currently a servicing agreement with them. So we're in the deal and have an opportunity to get involved much earlier in the process not waiting until it gets to 90 days. The SBA side of things kind of peaked in July. The outstanding problem loans dropped in August and September, not tremendously, but they're not continuing to climb period-over-period. So SBA as Ken said there is no specific industry or type of loan or location or anything. It's a very diversified nationwide, no real common themes within. On the consumer side of things we have less than 1% delinquency wholesalers RVs are not a problem. The resale value they were selling at a premium during COVID when nobody can get a new one. Resale has come down if we happen to have one come back to us. But outside of that we're not seeing any cracks whatsoever there. The CVS and the Walgreens is kind of the same story that we had with Red Lobster when everybody is worried about them 90, 120 days ago. We have about 35 CVS stores. Nothing is delinquent at the current time. Nothing is closed. Most of those are still in the middle of five-year plus lease agreements. We're not hearing from anybody. We have a service that checks like we just recently put on four CVS stores taking us up to, I think 31 or 32 outstanding. And in their region they were all four in the top performers. And they were in the upper 4% of performance within CVS. So again because we have the national footprint and the play we're buying Grade A, quality locations loan-to-value is still in that 47% 50% range and good, solid sponsors behind them. Walgreens is the same boat. We've not had anything go dark on us. We haven't got any notices of closure. We did have a Rite Aid (NYSE:US90274J5618=UBSS) where they had two in a town and they opted to close a new one on the outskirts versus the older one that was kind of in the heart of town. But the -- again the sponsor on that is continuing payments and is repurposing the stores. So the STL product right now we don't have a delinquent account. And if you remember over the years and we've gone through all kinds of crisis over the last 12 years. We've only had two loans go bad and on $2 billion in originations our total losses have been a little over $1 million. So we're not worried about the STL products, nor the consumer side. Time will tell. Obviously, rates going down particularly on the SBA will help. That does -- they're adjustable on a quarterly basis. So that will help lower payments and help the cash flow. And I think just give the SBA and the small business owner just kind of a light at the end of the tunnel that things are getting better and rates are coming their way. Inflation continues to slow. Obviously, there's certain spots that are still high. But as a whole it's coming down. So, I think everything is going in the right direction for them as well.
Brett Rabatin: That's a lot of great color. And just to clarify if I heard you correctly kind of the peak of SBA delinquencies in your portfolio is in July. There's another competitor that is out today with some adverse migration in their non-guaranteed SBA book and so they made a big provision. I know you can't comment on someone else's portfolio but I think that might be weighing somewhat on your stock as well as theirs.
David Becker: We had that same thought this morning when we saw the same thing you did. Yes, from our standpoint, we're -- as Ken said, we've taken specific provisions. If we think -- if it's over 90 days past due and we think we're going to have some kind of impairment on that non-guaranteed part we've already taken a provision against it. So, we evaluate them as they kind of break that barrier. But yes, we hit the top and it's come down a little bit. Who knows what we're still early in October here to 15th is kind of a universal payment date so we'll have a better handle in another week to 10 days. But we seem to be headed in the right direction at least stabilizing, I guess, if nothing else. So, yes, we read the same thing you read this morning and that was kind of a shock to us. We're not experiencing anything like they're experiencing.
Brett Rabatin: Okay. So, we're talking about the same institution. Okay. And then the other question I had was just I kind of figured you guys might wait a quarter or two for rates to come down, possibly a little more before you went and maybe built some liquidity and put on more CDs, but you seem to do that a little earlier. And if I heard right the production on CDs in the last month of the quarter was 4.45%. Was that correct? I'm just curious why you guys may be building a little--
David Becker: Yes, that is correct.
Brett Rabatin: Okay.
David Becker: It was not intentional. We had been lowering rates. We actually started lowering rates probably about a month before the Fed made a cut anticipating we were thinking it'd be 25 and we had lowered rates about 40 basis points on the 45-day period prior to the cut. But when it hit 50 basis points, the good and bad part about being an Internet institution is experienced by Silicon Valley and First Republic when they started to hit the wall, all the deposits were called in 24 hours, 36 hours. On our side, when the consumers and the business folks thought oh my God the bottom is falling out on the savings rates, they slammed in and bought CDs faster than we could lower the rates. We took them down another 40 basis points on the consumer side and 50 basis points on the commercial. We've cut off the inflow. But in that 24, 36, 48-hour period post the Fed announcement, they were flying through the door faster than we could lower the rate. So, lesson learned that that sword cuts both ways on withdrawals as well as deposits.
Brett Rabatin: Okay, that make sense. Great color guys. Thanks.
David Becker: Appreciate. Thanks Brett.
Operator: Thank you. Next question will be from Tim Switzer at KBW. Please go ahead.
Tim Switzer: Hey, good afternoon. Thanks for taking my questions.
David Becker: Hey, Tim.
Tim Switzer: I wanted to ask about the SBA origination outlook. I think you gave a pretty wide range of 15% to 25% in 2025. What are some of the factors that could drive it to the lower or high end of that range? Is it mostly rate driven? And then what are your expectations for pricing as we get into next year?
Ken Lovik: Well, our expectation right now is that we'll somewhere be in the range of say $525 million to $530 million of originations for this year. And we're targeting $600 million for next year. So, you do the math on that and you're probably in the range of 15. I think for us I think we've just -- we've put together just a really good team. We have a great team of BDOs out there and we have a great support team behind them on credit, servicing, closing. And it is reflected we've made this comment in the past couple of quarters. We continue to build the bench strength to support that growth and that will be key to achieving it. But I think we feel -- again we feel really good about the folks we have out there sourcing deals for us. And expect I guess if you look at kind of we have grown each quarter this year. So when you look at what we've done in the fourth quarter -- or excuse me the third quarter and what we're looking at for the fourth quarter it's not I don't think it's an unreasonable jump to get to that $600 million target for next year.
David Becker: Tim one of the uncertainties is the sales price in the secondary market that I think Ken made a comment that it had dropped 65 basis points third quarter over second quarter. As people try to get comfortable with what the Fed is going to do, we do two more 0.25 point drops in this quarter? The excess liquidity that we have on the balance sheet as I stated in my comments gives us a position if the bottom falls out in the secondary market we have cash and liquidity rather than sell a 10.5%, 11% yielding loan in the secondary market for 5.5%, 6% carry it on the books and we'll make up that difference in a 5, 6-month window of time. So we got a lot of optionality and a lot of flexibility going into 2025 and we can handle kind of whatever the market gives us on the SBA side. As Ken said we've got a team and an organization out here now that is just a pretty well-oiled machine that can produce the product and the volume we're looking for. I think I made a comment in the last call probably somewhere in that $600 million range might be kind of our cap looking at annual sales growth. But if we get it we can hold it on the books we can sell it in the secondary market. We'll do whatever is in the best interest of the institution. The good part about the excess cash is it gives us an awful lot of flexibility.
Tim Switzer: Okay. Great. Yes, that was really helpful. And then I wanted to ask about the NIM trajectory obviously pretty good expansion expected in Q4. How should we think about 2025 particularly the Fed cutting rates? I think last quarter you guys said each 25 basis points is about a $2.8 million annual benefit. Is that still the right range and with the loan growth you're expecting to put on? how should we expect the NIM to move next year?
Ken Lovik: Well, I think, last quarter that math was based on a static balance sheet. I think the wildcard for this is just the cash balance that we have and how that's deployed. I mean I think about -- if you just -- I'm going to give you some numbers here to think about that you can run some math on. But we got about $1.3 billion to $1.4 billion of what I'd call high beta or 100% beta deposits that are a combination of some brokered and some of our own deposits that are higher balance. But those reset immediately. So for every -- you can do the math on every 50 – 100, 25 basis points, 50 basis points, 75 basis points of cuts. Really offsetting that we probably got about $760 million of loans that would reprice either immediately or within three months in the case of SBA loans. We do have more variable rate loans on our balance sheet, but some are at price ceilings already. So you have that going one direction. But then we also have $1.4 billion of CDs with an average cost of close to 5% that mature over the next 12 months. And new production right now coming in the door in the month of October is 4.19%, 4.2%. So there's a lot of dollars of NII that we expect that we will pick up over the course of next year. How that translates exactly into margin is a little bit hard to project in terms -- because of the excess liquidity and what you're going to run it off at. But I -- just sitting here thinking about it I mean I would think that we would be able to at least expect perhaps 10 basis points of margin expansion a quarter just depending on how we get the liquidity out the door. And as David said too if there's optionality for holding SBA loans for example that would be incredibly accretive to net interest margin and net interest income. So we're still working on our forecast for next year. It's hard to -- you got the long rates that are doing something different than the short rates right now, and we got an election to get through. So I guess we'll see what rates happens to long rates after that. But I think all-in-all, just doing math and what we have today for just dollars of net interest income, I think we see a significant pickup next year.
David Becker: We still think we're going to hit the $3 mark that we had forecasted for this year. Closing out here in the fourth quarter, we'll be pretty close to almost $1 in income. We had forecasted $4 for next year. Obviously, with the Fed starting to move, that's a lock on our side. And it could -- depending on, as Ken just outlined for you, how the Fed rates move over the course of the year, that could move from 4 up to 5 pretty quickly. So we think we're going to finish strong here for this year and 2025 looks real, real good. Political and third world or overseas worlds off the table, if everything stays fairly stable in the political arena, in the world arena, we should have one bang up year in 2025.
Tim Switzer: Yes. We'll all pray for that. But thank you guys for the color. Appreciate it. Thank you.
David Becker: Thanks, Tim.
Operator: Next question will be from Nathan Race at Piper Sandler. Please go ahead.
Nathan Race: Hey, guys. Good afternoon. Thanks for taking my questions.
David Becker: Hey, Nate.
Nathan Race: Ken, I just want to clarify on the loan growth expectations for 4Q. Did you mention 1% to 2%? And then also be curious to get your preliminary thoughts on overall balance sheet growth expectations next year as well?
Ken Lovik: Yes. I think I said 1.5% to 2%, which probably is kind of in the range of where we were in the second -- or excuse me, the third quarter for loan growth.
Nathan Race: Okay. So that's not annualized?
Ken Lovik: I think as we said, maybe the wildcard for that could be if we don't like what we see in the secondary market for SBA, retaining some SBA loans, that could boost that a bit. But yes, probably in the range of growth that we saw this quarter.
Nathan Race: Okay. So that's 1% to 2% not annualized?
Ken Lovik: No, no, no, no. Yes, that's not annualized. That's just gross for the quarter.
Nathan Race: And then just any thoughts on how you see organic balance sheet growth in terms of both loans and deposits playing out next year as well, just given the fluid curve as well?
Ken Lovik: I think, yes, again, it kind of come back to with the liquidity we have on the balance sheet. And I guess I'll go back to my comments earlier about over $600 million of -- well, you got $600 million of CDs maturing in the next six months, $1.4 billion maturing next year, $250 million of higher cost brokered deposits maturing over the next six months. I mean, I expect that our balance sheet will be down in the fourth quarter at the end of the year relative to where we were at the end of the third quarter as we deploy some of that cash to just, again, pay down higher cost deposits. I think year-over-year, we're -- our total loan growth for this year, 2024 will probably be somewhere in the range of 7% to 9%. I think if we're doing what we're doing today, that number might be still the same. But again, I'll come back to what David said with the optionality we have on SBA loans and some other initiatives that we're working on that could drive further growth beyond that.
David Becker: We've been working with some of our fintechs. We have jaris in particular, that we kept thinking we would get the loan program up and running during the third quarter. We just made a small purchase here in October just to kind of validate and test everything to make sure all the mechanics and stuff are in play. They've got a couple of new clients coming their way. That one could jump up pretty quickly. We brought on two new programs here in the last 30 to 45 days in the fintech space that could have some opportunities for us. So as Ken said, there's a lot of options and a lot of play, and we're just kind of taking stuff day by day, but it's -- everything really does look good for us going forward.
Nathan Race: Got it. That's helpful. And then just within that context, a high-level strategic question. Just with the momentum you're seeing on the SBA side of things and with some of the partnerships, just curious if it makes sense to maybe slow balance sheet growth, particularly just given coming out of 3Q, it seems like the loan and deposit growth is margin dilutive, and that may change and should change with Fed cuts and depending on the forward curve or depending on how the yield curve plays out. But just curious on your thoughts around slowing balance sheet growth and just leaning on some of those more profitable lines of business. And then just build capital and perhaps resume buying back the stock just given where it's trading relative to tangible book?
David Becker: Well, hopefully you're spot on. We have a lot of flexibility without growing the balance sheet to remix things and get higher earnings and higher yield. We can get that 10% growth technically right now with the cash we have on the balance sheet. So there's no need to bring in deposits for the sake of deposits or grow the balance sheet. So we agree with you 100%. It's kind of remix things a little bit maximize earnings and not necessarily pump up the balance sheet. And we're spot on. I would hope that the stock appreciates quickly as we add better earnings to the bottom line and gets back towards that book value plus. But I don't think being real honest in 2025 that I don't want to set the stage that we're going to go back and do a big stock repurchase, because if we get into that 40 range it doesn't make a lot of sense. I'd rather build capital and save that for a rainy day or save it for a position. We got a couple of sub debt items coming up. We could take the extra capital and pay down some sub debt and get the stability in the capital network. So we might have other options for it versus buying back stock.
Nathan Race: Understood. Very helpful. And Ken I think you mentioned expenses should be up a little bit just based on some commission costs tied to the similar SBA revenue expectations and some other investments. But just curious how you're preliminary thinking about expense growth in 2025. I know it's going to be contingent on the SBA revenue side of things, but assuming SBA revenue continues to ramp up by maybe at least 5%. Just curious how you're thinking about the overall expense trajectory within that context?
Ken Lovik: Yeah. Well I think we're we've done quite a bit of hiring this year to build out the SBA platform and enhance risk management and add some positions around the country as I like to say add bench strength. So we'll have a full year's run rate of folks there. But if I'm thinking about next year, you're probably 7% to 8% expense growth for next year for the year.
David Becker: I was going to guess 9% to 10%, so blend this together…
Ken Lovik: You get the ball out of the park on SBA then we'll be closer to that 9% to 10%.
David Becker: Yeah.
Nathan Race: And it's in the ballpark out on SBA is that growing SBA revenue 5% 10% next year? Or how do you quantify that I guess?
David Becker: Well, I guess on the sales volume side of things as Ken said we're going to end up a little over $500 million probably this year and we're looking at $600 million next year. So we got a nice bump up, which also if you take a look where we're at this quarter, it's only going to get bigger through the course of the year as long as premiums don't fall apart on us. And as they start to or we take that excess growth into next year and put it on the balance sheet, we got a real chance of picking up a nice uptick in earnings out of SBA either way it goes in the secondary market or on the balance sheet. So it will compensate for the growth in the expense side.
Nathan Race: Got it. And then just one last one just from a housekeeping perspective, any thoughts on the tax rate going forward?
David Becker: Depends on who wins the election.
Ken Lovik: You know, what I think right now we're probably thinking that probably like fourth quarter will be in the same tax rate area as it was in the third quarter. With higher earnings we do get a very strong benefit from our public finance portfolio. But as our -- just our pre-tax earnings continue to grow that benefit on a percentage basis is less. So I would think our tax rate for next year with higher earnings is probably going to migrate over the course of the year from maybe ranging from anywhere from call it a high 8% to somewhere perhaps as high as 11% to 12% by the end of the year. It's kind of the way I would look at it.
Nathan Race: Got it. Very helpful. I appreciate all the color. Thanks guys.
Ken Lovik: Thank you.
David Becker: Thanks, Nate.
Operator: Next question will be from George Sutton at Craig-Hallum. Please go ahead.
George Sutton: Thank you. David, I wanted to test one statement you made in your prepared comments you mentioned we in Q3 were firing on all cylinders. I think if you really thought about it that you might say firing on many cylinders. I'm just curious what you think firing on all cylinders should look like?
David Becker: I think it's the bump up, George, so we have coming here for the fourth quarter. And then, if the Fed continues to drop rates significantly through the course of 2025, we're going to just kind of blow the roof off in earnings and structure here in the institution. We're taking it back to the racing analogy. We'll set a track record by the end of the year. So, we've just got a lot of good things going every place. And we got it for us and our balance sheet historically has been unbelievably pristine. We've got a bump or two on the -- a little bit on the SBA side and a little bit on the franchise end but that's all manageable. We'll get a handle on it. So I think the future is really, really looking good for us. The gentleman you headed my way, we've had a good conversation. I think there might be some opportunities there. We're getting a lot of good inquiries from people kind of the dust is just settling. The FinTech space, we wound down a client here over the last quarter, who just cannot raise any additional capital. They had a great program. They had a great product but they just couldn't get the capital to get there. And as the institutions kind of pull back on some of the BC stuff, there might be opportunities to actually pick up a FinTech or two and put that product into our mix. There are other very solid programs that are looking for solid players that understand and can provide the services they're looking for. So, I just think we have an awful lot of good things going on within our product mix and good things coming to us from the outside world. So 2025 looks really strong.
George Sutton: Fabulous. I did want to say congratulations to Ken and Nicole and Ann and Tim and Nick and Dustin and Maris fellow, Indiana graduates on the seven and will start to the year.
David Becker: Yes. Believe me they had their first sellout football game last year in like 50 years. So, it's -- yes it's a very -- a lot of cheering for basketball over the years but it's been very rare. A lot of good tailgating but most people just tailgate and pass on the games. They got a full house now. So that's great. Thank you.
George Sutton: Thanks guys.
David Becker: Thanks George.
Operator: At this time, I would like to turn the call back over to David Becker for closing remarks.
David Becker: Thank you, Sylvie. Thanks everybody for joining us today. As I said we've kind of produced some really consistent improving results throughout 2024. We're extremely confident in our ability to deliver a strong finish to the year. And as we look to 2025 and beyond we're extremely excited about what the future holds. Strong performance of the lending teams, including continued execution in the SBA and construction area, emerging growth opportunities with key FinTech partnerships are expected to drive greater more diversified revenue growth. We combine that with the prospects for a more favorable interest rate environment and the positive impact that will have on deposit costs. We believe we are very well positioned to achieve stronger earnings over the next several quarters. As fellow shareholders, we remain committed to driving improved profitability and enhanced shareholder value. We thank you for your support and wish you a good afternoon.
Operator: Thank you, sir. Ladies and gentlemen, this does indeed conclude your conference call for today. Once again, thank you for attending. And at this time, we do ask that you please disconnect your lines.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.