On Monday, BMO Capital maintained its Underperform rating on Lemonade Inc . (NYSE:LMND), with a steady price target of $13.00. The firm observed that Lemonade's shares have surged by more than 100% quarter-to-date. The significant rise in the company's stock price is attributed to factors beyond the company's fundamental performance, as consensus forward EPS (Earnings Per Share) revisions have remained relatively unchanged.
According to BMO Capital, the sharp increase in Lemonade's share value can be linked to a mix of retail stock trading patterns observed since the U.S. election, heightened anticipation for Lemonade's Investor Day scheduled for November 19, and the parallel surge in the stock of ROOT, another player in the insurance technology sector. It is important to note that ROOT's forward EPS revisions have materially improved, which is not the case for Lemonade.
Lemonade's stock performance has been particularly notable given that the consensus on the company's earnings outlook has not shifted significantly. This disconnect between the company's stock price movement and its EPS revisions suggests that external factors, rather than company-specific fundamentals, are influencing investor behavior.
The upcoming Investor Day for Lemonade is one of the key events that market participants are looking forward to. Such events often provide investors with deeper insights into a company's strategy, performance, and outlook, which can have a substantial impact on the stock's movement.
Lemonade, Inc., which operates within the insuretech industry, is experiencing a trading pattern that is currently being mirrored by ROOT, although the latter has seen a material improvement in its forward EPS revisions. This comparison highlights the divergence in the performance metrics of the two companies, despite similar trends in their stock prices.
In other recent news, Lemonade Inc. has reported significant financial growth in its third quarter. The company's in-force premiums rose by 24% to $889 million, and the customer count increased by 17% to 2.3 million. Gross profit saw a considerable surge of 71% year-over-year to $37 million, and net cash flow reached $48 million. Piper Sandler adjusted its outlook on Lemonade, raising the price target while maintaining a neutral rating, recognizing the company's performance improvements.
The company's strong third-quarter performance was marked by a positive swing in its free cash flow (FCF) of $14 million. Despite a minor dip in annual dollar retention to 87%, Lemonade has been strategically reducing its less profitable home customer segment to concentrate on more profitable growth avenues.
Recent developments include Lemonade's strategic plans for expansion, especially in auto insurance. Analysts from various firms anticipate further improvements in 2026, with Lemonade's Q4 2024 in-force premium projection being between $940 million to $944 million, and revenue projection being $144 million to $146 million. The company aims to achieve consistent positive cash flow from operations by the end of 2024.
InvestingPro Insights
Recent data from InvestingPro adds context to BMO Capital's analysis of Lemonade Inc. (NYSE:LMND). The stock's significant return over the last week (20.66%) and strong performance over the last month (63.54%) align with BMO's observation of a surge in share price. InvestingPro data shows that LMND is trading near its 52-week high, with the current price at 98.28% of its peak.
InvestingPro Tips highlight that LMND's stock generally trades with high price volatility, which is consistent with the recent sharp price movements discussed in the article. Additionally, the tip that analysts do not anticipate the company will be profitable this year supports BMO's stance on maintaining an Underperform rating.
It's worth noting that while the stock has shown impressive returns, LMND is not profitable over the last twelve months, with a negative P/E ratio of -9.45. This fundamental weakness contrasts with the stock's recent performance, reinforcing BMO's view that the price surge may be driven by factors beyond company fundamentals.
For investors seeking a more comprehensive analysis, InvestingPro offers 11 additional tips for LMND, providing a deeper understanding of the company's financial health and market position.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.