ANZ Group Holdings Ltd (ASX:ANZ) saw its shares fall by approximately 0.94% in afternoon trade on Tuesday, reflecting a broader market downturn with the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) also down 0.8%. The decline in ANZ's share price comes amid a downgrade from Morgan Stanley (NYSE:MS), one of Australia's leading analysts, which has cast a pessimistic view on the bank's future prospects.
Key Concerns Highlighted by Morgan Stanley
Morgan Stanley analyst Richard Wiles expressed several concerns about ANZ's outlook. He highlighted that while the bank's institutional division is profitable, its revenue has likely peaked. The analyst also pointed to risks associated with ANZ's digital banking initiative, ANZ Plus, which is aimed at competing with other major banks like Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX:CBA). Wiles noted that this initiative could lead to higher deposit pricing pressures and execution risks.
Additionally, Wiles mentioned several other challenges for ANZ, including slowing Australian mortgage growth, a weaker economic outlook in New Zealand compared to Australia, and smaller potential provision releases and buybacks than those of its peers. He also indicated that dividend growth might be modest, given that the bank's payout ratio is already above the target range.
Downgrade and Price Target (NYSE:TGT) Adjustment
Due to these concerns, Morgan Stanley downgraded its rating on ANZ shares from "equal-weight" to "underweight." The firm also reduced its price target for ANZ shares by approximately 6%, bringing it down to $26.20. This new price target suggests a potential further decline of around 7% from the current share price, reflecting the broker's cautious stance on the stock.
Broader Concerns for the Banking Sector
In addition to ANZ, Morgan Stanley's Wiles expressed concerns about the valuation of the major Australian banks in general. He argued that while the banks have experienced a re-rating, their current trading multiples may not be sustainable given the modest growth and return profiles. Wiles suggested that the share prices might already reflect the anticipated benefits of rate cuts, a soft landing, and reduced competition in retail banking. He also noted that loan growth is expected to remain below 5%, with margins recovering only modestly, while costs could continue to rise and provision releases may be smaller and delayed.
ANZ Share Price Performance in 2024
Despite the recent downgrade and market concerns, ANZ's share price has seen an increase of 8.5% since the start of 2024, outpacing the ASX 200's rise of around 4%. However, the recent pessimistic outlook from Morgan Stanley may signal potential headwinds for the bank in the near term.
The downgrade from Morgan Stanley reflects a cautious outlook for ANZ Group Holdings and the broader Australian banking sector. While ANZ has shown resilience in its share price performance, the concerns highlighted by analysts suggest that investors should be mindful of potential challenges ahead. The emphasis on ANZ Plus and its digital transformation efforts, along with the broader economic conditions in Australia and New Zealand, will be key areas to watch as the bank navigates this uncertain landscape.