Kinsale Capital (NYSE: KNSL), an E&S insurance specialist, experienced a 20% drop in its stock price on Thursday, despite posting strong quarterly results. The firm's future growth prospects, as outlined by management, seemed to unsettle investors, leading to the sell-off.
The firm has been known for its unique underwriting policies based on deep expertise in areas such as small business casualty, construction, professional liability, marine, aviation, and product recalls. This niche focus has allowed Kinsale more flexibility in policy pricing, thus contributing to healthy margins.
Despite exceeding analysts' expectations with net earned premiums growing 39% YoY and net income surging 131% YoY, backed by gains on their investment portfolio, the company's stock saw a significant sell-off. This is likely due to concerns about its premium valuation after CEO Michael Kehoe projected a future growth rate of 10% to 20% as market competition normalizes.
Since its IPO in 2016, Kinsale has demonstrated robust growth with total revenue growing at a compounded annual rate of 40%. Its current valuation stands at 7.1 times sales, 28.8 times earnings, and 23.4 times forward earnings. These figures are significantly higher than the industry average and competitor Markel (NYSE: NYSE:MKL).
Insurance is a cyclical industry that is influenced by claims paid out on policies and industry competition. In recent years, higher claims costs and dwindling competition have allowed companies to raise premiums. This "hard" insurance market is expected to continue through next year according to Fitch Ratings, which benefits E&S insurers like Kinsale who can cover high-profit policies that others won't. Softening conditions are not expected until 2025.
The recent drop in Kinsale's stock may be a result of some investors cashing in at what they perceive as a high valuation. As Kinsale grows and industry market conditions normalize, its CEO expects its growth rate to settle between 10% and 20% annually.
InvestingPro Insights
InvestingPro real-time data shows that Kinsale Capital has a market capitalization of 7950M USD and a P/E ratio of 28.58. The company's revenue growth over the last twelve months as of Q3 2023 was an impressive 42.32%, and the price/book ratio stood at 8.62.
InvestingPro Tips suggest that Kinsale Capital has high earnings quality, with free cash flow exceeding net income. The company's revenue growth has been accelerating and it yields a high return on invested capital. Additionally, strong earnings have allowed management to continue dividend payments, which have been raised for seven consecutive years. Notably, seven analysts have revised their earnings upwards for the upcoming period.
These insights from InvestingPro, which offers a wealth of additional tips and data, provide a more nuanced understanding of Kinsale Capital's financial health and future prospects. It's noteworthy that despite the recent drop in the company's stock price, the data and tips suggest a robust financial standing and potential for future growth.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.